|
Click title to expand and show summary -- Click here to hide summaries
Complete Issue > Volume XV, Number 15, Monday, November 10, 2008 (November 10th, 2008 — $ 36.00) Click here to add this article to your cart
R. Lewis Dark:
Growth Conundrum Confronts
Quest and LabCorp
AFTER MORE THAN TWO DECADES of buying up almost every attractive
laboratory asset that came up for sale�and with few lab acquisition candidates
left to buy�Laboratory Corporation of America and Quest Diagnostics Incorporated
find themselves in an interesting conundrum. As public companies, any increase
in the value of their shares is directly linked to growth rates in specimen
volume, revenue, and net profit.
On the other hand, simply because of
their huge size relative to the laboratory services marketplace, the ability of
the two blood brothers to achieve sustained rates of growth of 10% and 15% per
year is a major challenge. Let me explain why the numbers work against
them.
By year�s end, Quest Diagnostics will post revenue of around $7.7
billion. Revenue at LabCorp will be in the range of $4.5 billion. Thus, for each
lab company to grow revenue by 10% during 2009, Quest will require $770 million
in new business and LabCorp will require $450 million. That�s the need for $1.2
billion in new business between them, and in just one year!
Thus, as you
will read on pages 10-16 in this issue, each of the national lab companies
havemultiple strategies to generate new specimens,more revenue, and greater net
profits. The days of rapid growth in revenue and net profits because of
acquisitions and conversion of conventional Pap smear business to thin-layer Pap
tests are long past. Both national labs must successfully execute a series of
business growth initiatives to generate additional revenues and increased net
profit in today�s competitive lab marketplace.
This is why the laboratory
services marketplace has seemed rather quiet over the past year. The two
national laboratories are adjusting to a market where growth-by-acquisition is
no longer the primary strategy to achieve increased revenue and net profit. Now
each company must craft a long-term business plan to deliver sustained growth
that satisfies investors.
That is why the conversation is shifting at
both LabCorp and Quest Diagnostics to new opportunities in genetic and molecular
testing. It is why there are plans to serve the developing wellness and
prevention emphasis in healthcare. That brings employers onto the radar screen
as potential customers. And, I predict that Quest Diagnostics and LabCorp will
steadily increase their presence and activity in other countries. LabCorp�s new
agreement in Abu Dhabi is one example of this. (See Page 18.)
Medi-Cal Hits Pathologist For $6.4 Million Payment
Medi-Cal Hits Pathologist
For $6.4 Million Payment
CEO SUMMARY: Once again,
government health bureaucrats are overreaching in their efforts to reduce
spending and collect money from any source. A California pathologist has been
hit with a Medi-Cal demand for $6.4 million in repayments, simply because he
served as laboratory director for two lab companies that Medi-Cal knew had
closed before auditors requested records. Without a successful legal challenge
to this Medi-Cal position, a dangerous precedent may be
set.
Cytology Lab Uses Lean to Simplify Processes
First Lean project
improves staff productivity while cutting 132 work steps in histology to just
82
CEO SUMMARY: Like many
labs today, the gynecologic cytology laboratory at the University of Iowa
Hospitals and Clinics had a pre- and post-analytical work flow with many complex
steps. This work flow�heavily influenced by a legacy of previous information
systems�was inefficient, contained unnecessary redundancies, and lacked
systematic measures for preventing errors. That all changed when the Department
of Pathology did its first Lean project, greatly improving work flow and staff
productivity.
LabCorp And Quest Report 3rd Quarter Financial Performance
Siimiillarr
Sttrrattegiies�Achiieved by Diifffferrentt Tacttiics
CEO SUMMARY: In third
quarter earnings reports, both national lab companies posted modest gains in
specimen volume, revenue, and net profit. More telling is the relative quiet in
the current market for lab testing services. With no obvious opportunities to
fuel double-digit rates of growth, the two blood brothers are pushing forward
with similar business strategies. However, each lab company is pursuing those
strategies with uniquely different tactics and emphasis. Here's an in-depth
comparison of events unfolding with Quest Diagnostics and
LabCorp.
LAB
BRIEFS: MASSACHUSETTS LAW MANDATES CPOE USE BY HOSPITALS IN 2012 HCA AND
PAML EXPAND LAB OUTREACH VENTURE IN SALT LAKE CITY MOVE TO HIPAA 5010
PROPOSED FOR APRIL 2010 LABCORP INKS DEAL TO ESTABLISH LABORATORY IN EMIRATE
OF ABU DHABI
INTELLIGENCE: Late &
Latent
MEDTOX REPORTS REVENUE GAIN FOR
THIRD QUARTER
GENOMIC HEALTH GROWS RAPIDLY
Complete Issue > Volume XV, Number 14, Monday, October 20, 2008 (October 20th, 2008 — $ 36.00) Click here to add this article to your cart
Commentary by R. Lewis Dark: >> JOIN NOW!
Genome Sequencing Promises to be Disruptive EVERYONE SHOULD CAREFULLY READ OUR LEAD STORY ON THE FACING PAGE. Titled “Rapid Gene Sequencing Predicted by Mid-2009,” it is a revealing look at the declaration of California-based Complete Genetics that, in less than eight months, it will begin delivering full human genome sequences priced at $5,000 each to interested customers at a cost of only $1,000 to itself! Complete Genomics’ announcement represents the same paradigm shifting earthquake in genetic medicine that occurred back on May 11, 1998.
That’s the day when J. Craig Venter, Ph.D., and his partner, Perkin-Elmer, announced their plans to map the entire human genome for a cost under $300 million and do it in within three to four years. At the time, the Human Genome Project was about halfway through a 15-year, $3 billion project to complete the first full sequence of the human genome.
THE DARK REPORT predicted that Venter’s effort would succeed and, as it did, it would accelerate both the accumulation of genetic knowledge and the speed with which it was converted into clinically useful molecular diagnostic tests.We wrote: “Those laboratories and pathology practices which flourish in the year 2005 will be the ones which were early implementers of emerging genetics-based diagnostics.” (See TDR, June 15, 1998.)
Venter achieved his bold goal in just 25 months. It was June 25, 2000, when President Bill Clinton publicly announced the successful sequencing of the human genome and recognized the roles of both Venter and Frances S. Collins, M.D., Ph.D., who had led the Human Genome Consortium, in this accomplishment. For the lab industry, by 2005, a host of new lab companies had emerged to offer a growing menu of molecular tests. Molecular assays for infectious diseases and certain cancers were transforming clinical practices, giving truth to THE DARK REPORT’s 1998 prophesy.
Now THE DARK REPORT sees a parallel moment of disruption in genetic medicine. Complete Genomics and a host of competitors are about to transform human genome sequencing, dropping price and speed while opening the doors to vast amounts of new knowledge about DNA, RNA, and the human proteome. Pathologists and lab directors should prepare for an accelerating flood of new insights about genes and proteins. Many of these discoveries will rapidly lead to new laboratory tests that offer physicians and patients more precise tools for diagnosis, therapeutic decisions, and patient monitoring.
Genome Sequencing Promises to be Disruptive..............Page 2
Rapid Human Genome Sequencing Predicted by Mid-2009 ..................................................Page 3
ICD-10 Conversion Costs Underestimated by HHS.................................................Page 7
Hospital Labs Have New Options For Molecular Diagnostics..............................................Page 9
Molecular Dx Update: LabCorp’s Ovarian Cancer Test Generates FDAWarning Letter ......................................Page 12
Lab Briefs: Siemens, BioImagene, Clarient University of Pennsylvania,Mayo Clinic .......................Page 13
Pathology Administrators’ Boot Camp To Address Three Trends ................................................Page 15
Intelligence: Late-Breaking Lab News ............................Page 19
Complete Issue > Volume XV, Number 13, Monday, September 29, 2008 (September 29th, 2008 — $ 36.00) Click here to add this article to your cart
|
| |
>> Become a
Charter Member Today! |
|

|
R. Lewis Dark:
Lean Six Sigma Takes Root in
Labs & Hospitals
LAST WEEK, MORE THAN 300 ENTHUSIASTIC LAB AND HOSPITAL PROFESSIONALS
from 11 different countries around the globe crowded into Atlanta for the Second Annual Lab Quality Confab.
They were gathered to hear the latest success stories and breakthroughs in how
laboratories and hospitals are using quality management methods like Lean and
Six Sigma.
If anyone remains skeptical about the value of Lean and Six
Sigma to improve outcomes and workflow in healthcare, more than 50 presentations
and case studies by some of America�s first rank laboratories, hospitals, and
health systems demonstrated the remarkable gains that well-executed process
improvement projects generated for their organizations. Evidently I am not alone
in believing in the value of Lean and Six Sigma management methods to play a
role in meeting the healthcare system's challenges of improving quality,
reducing errors, and lowering costs. The demand for experienced Lean and Six
Sigma professionals to work in the nation�s hospitals and health systems is so
great that management recruiters are struggling to find candidates to fill these
positions.Healthcare magazines are writing stories about this staffing gap.
Our Editor, Robert Michel, tells me that this year�s speakers at Lab
Quality Confab displayed much more sophistication as they discussed improvement
projects in every area of clinical laboratory and pathology laboratory
operations.
I take that as an early warning for those laboratories and
pathology groups which have yet to implement Lean and Six Sigma. The competitive
bar is being raised by your peers and colleagues! Just as GeneralMotors, Ford,
and Chrysler found themselves outcompeted by Japanese car manufacturers (using
these quality management methods) in the 1970s and 1980s, so also will those
labs and hospitals who are slow to understand the power of Lean and Six Sigma to
lift their performance�and their profits�find themselves at competitive
disadvantage in the laboratory services marketplace.
Across the American
healthcare system, the pace of change and reform seems to be intensifying.
Adoption of Lean and Six Sigma by labs, hospitals, and health systems is playing
a major role in this transformation. In coming weeks and months, THE DARK
REPORT and Dark Daily will bring you
"the best of Lab Quality Confab" so you and your management team can learn from
these top-performing laboratories, hospitals, and health systems.
iTunes Business Model For Digital Path Scans
Things heat up in digital
pathology market as BioImagene introduces 99� per slide
pricing
CEO SUMMARY: If
BioImagene's CEO is to be believed, the company is ready to deliver a digital
pathology system that is robust and affordable, even in settingswith just two or
three pathologists. One key to the BioImagene strategy is �per scan� pricing
that avoids the need for upfront capital to acquire its system. Confident
investors just pumped $26 million into BioImagene and, as of this month, its new
CEO is a 20-year veteran of Siemens,who was leader of its Image and Knowledge
Management business.
Illinois Pathologists Dodge Medicaid CP Payment Cut
Illinois Medicaid Program
was prepared to end payment for clinical pathology professional
services
CEO SUMMARY:
Pathologists in Illinois acted swiftly to this month's announcement that the
Illinois Medicaid program would cease to directly pay pathologists directly for
clinical pathology professional services.The newpolicywas to take effect on
October 1, 2008. As this issue of THE DARK REPORT goes to press, there is
breaking news that educational efforts by the Illinois Society of Pathology have
led the state's Medicaid program to rescind implementation of the announced cuts
to CP professional services.
LAB BRIEFS: MED TECH SHORTAGE CAUSES DEVRY UNIVERSITY TO OFFER MT
DEGREE, VOLUME GROWTH IN MOLECULAR TESTING BOOSTS TWO PUBLIC LABS, CANCER LAB
CLERK FACES CHARGES IN PATIENT ID THEFT
Implementation Date For ICD-10 Is Proposed
Department of Health and
Human Services publishes ICD-10 launch date of October 1,
2011
CEO SUMMARY: Even though
the transition from ICD-9 to ICD-10 will not be required until 2011,
laboratories and pathology groups should have a transition plan in place.
ICD-10�s 155,000 seven-digit codes will replace the 17,000 five-digit codes of
ICD- 9. Because of major changes in the design of ICD-10, extensive training of
laboratory coders will be necessary to ensure a smooth implementation. Referring
physicians and their staff must also be trained and ready for ICD-10 if labs are
to minimize denied claims.
Phlebotomy Automation Likely To Be Next Trend
Goal will be to reduce
variation in outcomes and raise the quality of individual work
processes
CEO SUMMARY: Here's a
prediction that automation of work processes for phlebotomy, specimen
collection, and specimen transport may be the next trend. Unfolding developments
in the United States are creating a situation parallel to what was seen in
Japanese hospital laboratories more than two decades ago�and led to the world's
first automated solutions for clinical laboratories. Another factor to enable
this trend are recent advances in technology and
miniaturization.
INTELLIGENCE: Late &
Latent
NANO BIOSENSORS CAN DETECT
MICROORGANISMS
ADD
TO: Biosensors |
Complete Issue > Volume XV, Number 11, Monday, August 18, 2008 (August 18th, 2008 — $ 36.00) Click here to add this article to your cart
R. Lewis Dark:
Two Healthcare Trends
Collide on These Pages
THIS ISSUE OF THE DARK REPORT YOU NOW HOLD IN YOUR HANDS
demonstrates the perfect intersection of two trends. One trend, transparency in
health outcomes and a public expectation of reduced medical errors, is a direct
threat to laboratories which fail to deliver high-quality and accurate lab test
results. The other trend is the way quality management systems (QMS) are being
“pulled” into laboratory operations and healthcare.
This first trend is
analyzed on pages 16-18, where you will read how the widely-publicized
deficiencies of several labs and pathologists in Canada has become a public
issue. To bolster public confidence in laboratory testing, pathologists with the
Canadian Association of Pathology (CAP) are creating a voluntary proficiency
testing program. It is starting with breast cancer testing for estrogen
receptors (ERs) and progesterone receptors (PRs). As an interesting side note,
Canada’s single-payer model health system has yet to step forward and pay for
this proficiency testing program.
The second trend—involving the use of
quality management systems, including "ISO:15189 Medical Laboratories"—is
assessed on pages 3-5. This is one of the lab industry’s first alerts to this
emerging development. Our Editor, Robert L. Michel, considers it important
enough that he has assembled an impressive panel of experts to speak on QMS at
the upcoming Lab Quality Confab http://www.labqualitycofab.com on
September 24-25, 2008. That promises to be a revealing series of presentations
and I recommend that clinical labs and pathology groups already confronting use
of quality management systems be present at this unique event. First, it is not
likely that this same assemblage of experts on ISO:15189 and similar quality
management systems will be gathered at one time and place again soon. Second,
Robert has a knack for pulling together a spectrum of experts, who,
collectively, deliver an amazing amount of information and unmatched strategic
wisdom. That’s a lot of bang for your buck!
I will also step forward with
another recommendation. I suggest that you use the two intelligence briefings
referenced above as discussion points for a strategic session in your laboratory
or pathology group practice. I’ll bet that, as your leadership team talks
through the implications of trend one—outcomes transparency and public
expectations—and contrasts that with trend two—use of QMS to continuously
improve quality, productivity, and performance—it is going to agree on some
surprising new directions for your laboratory.
First U.S. Labs Nearing ISO:15189 Accreditation
ISO:15189 likely to
influence upcoming reform and revisions to CLIA licensing
requirements
CEO SUMMARY:
Laboratories, hospitals, and other healthcare providers in the United States
will increasingly be required to adopt quality management systems (QMS) as part
of their regular operational routine. This is consistent with trends in other
developed countries. Several U.S. laboratories are in the process of gaining
accreditation under "ISO:1519 Medical Laboratories." These developments will be
discussed at the upcoming Lab Quality Confab in Atlanta next
month.
Independent Labs Won't Get Medicare PQRI Bonuses
Independent labs learn
they will not get same Medicare PQRI payments as other
pathologists
CEO SUMMARY: Medicare
does not intend to make bonus payments this year to independent labs currently
reporting quality information for breast and colon cancer cases. The federal
claims payment system is unable to pay independent labs for participating in the
federal physician quality reporting initiative (PQRI). But physician pathology
groups participating in PQRI will receive the bonus payments as expected. CMS
has yet to formally acknowledge this problem, leaving labs with unanswered
questions.
MT/MLT Distance Learning Goal of Collaboration
ARUP and Weber State team
up to make it easier for interested lab staff to advance
skills
CEO SUMMARY: To
encourage more students to pursue medical technology (MT) and medical laboratory
technician (MLT) degrees, ARUP Laboratories and Weber State University (WSU) are
collaborating to promote the distance learning programs offered at WSU. Online
students can work any shift and take courses anytime (day, night, or on
weekends), thereby making education more accessible to prospective students.
Distance learning is likely to be an important source of education for new
technical staff for labs.
NEWSMAKER INTERVIEW: Successful Laboratories in the Future Will
Brand Themselves, Add Value
CEO SUMMARY: At the most
recent Executive War College(see http://www.executivewarcollege.com), Kerry
Kaplan, President of Healthcare Connections in Natick, Massachusetts, discussed
the results of his national survey of managed care executives. In part one of
this interview, Kaplan described the results of his survey, along with advice on
how laboratories can build a positive, ongoing partnership with local managed
care plans. In part two, he explains what steps pathologists and lab directors
can take to become partners with their health plan customers to improve the
delivery of healthcare. He also explains how labs have an opportunity to work
more closely with payers that are interested in saving money on complex,
expensive cases. Kaplan ends by stressing the need for labs to have a branding
strategy.
Canadian Pathologists Start PT Testing for ER/PR
Voluntary proficiency
testing program created in response to public disclosure of test
deficiencies
CEO SUMMARY: Experts
point out that widely publicized episodes of lab testing deficiencies in several
provinces are signs that chronic underfunding of lab testing services is a key
factor in these failures. To restore public confidence in breast cancer testing,
the Canadian Association of Pathologists is developing a voluntary pro ficiency
testing system for hospital labs to improve the accuracy and reproducibility of
breast cancer markers, including estrogen receptor, progesterone receptor, and
other clinical IHC tests.
INTELLIGENCE: Late &
Latent
NEW BLOOD TEST FOR COLORECTAL
CANCER
CALIF. REGULATORS SEND COMPLIANCE LETTER TO DNA
DIRECT
Complete Issue > Volume XV, Number 10, Monday, July 28, 2008 (July 28th, 2008 — $ 36.00) Click here to add this article to your cart
R. Lewis Dark:
Lab Testing Hits Two Home
Runs For Patients
MANY OF US POINT OUT THAT LABORATORY MEDICINE is an undervalued and
under-utilized asset within the American healthcare system. Lab testing is
generally a minimal cost relative to the total episode of care, yet lab testing
provides essential knowledge to help clinicians make a quick, accurate diagnosis
and confidently select appropriate therapies.
Like the late comedian
Rodney Dangerfield,many lab directors and pathologists feel like "I don�t get no
respect!", particularly when negotiating contracts withmanaged care plans.
Seldomis the true value of laboratory testing acknowledged by payers,
particularly in the form of adequate reimbursement.
However, this
situation may be on the verge of changing. In this issue of THE DARK
REPORT, we provide intelligence briefings on two important home runs hit by
laboratories during the past 24 months. First up is our coverage about the
explosion in vitamin D testing. Labs across the country are reporting that
vitamin D test volumes have doubled and tripled over themost recent 12months!
ARUP Laboratories tells us that about one-third of the vitamin D test
results indicate that the individual is vitamin D-deficient. This fact is
evidence that physicians are using the test appropriately. (See pages
3-5.)
That remarkable lab testing home run is followed by the story
of another, even * more amazing lab testing home run. At Washington Hospital
Center (WHC) in Washington, DC, a rapid PNA FISH test for bloodstream
infections, combined with real-time results reporting to the attending
physician, has contributed to an 83% drop in patient mortality in ICU
settings�and a 53% overall reduction in patient mortality related to bloodstream
infections! (See pages 6-9.)
The unique twist to the WHC
experience is that these dramatic reductions in patient mortality only came
after the procedure for reporting the PNA FISH tests was changed to incorporate
a personal phone call to the attending physician, to ensure he/she got the
results in real time. Now comes the next challenge for the lab industry. Will
Medicare and private payers recognize this value provided by labs to their
referring clinicians?
Will Medicare and private payers establish
reasonable reimbursement for these testing services? Too often in the past,
payers publicly promote the importance of patients getting these tests, while,
in private, they excoriate labs for not controlling test utilization and
financially penalize them for the higher volume of testing that was
performed.
Vitamin D Test Volumes Doubled in Past Year
Growing awareness about
vitamin D deficiency causes patients and physicians to order more
tests
CEO SUMMARY: Across the
nation, labs report a near doubling in the volume of vitamin D tests they are
performing. This is a success for laboratorymedicine and an appropriate use of
diagnostics tests as physicians strive for early detection and early
intervention of vitamin D deficiency. However, the next chapter in this story
will be equally important. Will Medicare and private payers recognize that, per
evidence-based medicine guidelines, this testing is justified and labs should
not be punished for increased utilization?
53% Drop in Mortality From Lab Report Change
Study links use of rapid
molecular test and real-time results reporting to improved
outcomes
CEO SUMMARY: At
Washington Hospital Center, it was unclear if the use of a rapid molecular assay
for blood infections was changing outcomes until a new, real-time lab results
reporting protocol required the lab to deliver the test results personally to
the attending physician in real time. A study with a control group provided
convincing evidence that use of the rapid molecular test, in combination with
real time test reporting,may be associated with dramatic reduction in mortality
and improved patient outcomes.
NEWSMAKER INTERVIEW: Labs Should Build Payer Relationships To
Improve Commodity Pricing
CEO SUMMARY: At the most
recent Executive War College, Kerry Kaplan, President of Healthcare Connections
in Natick, Massachusetts, discussed the results of his national survey of health
plan executives on their attitudes toward clinical laboratories. It will be no
surprise that these managed care executives consider lab testing services to be
a commodity. What will be a surprise are Kaplan�s recommendations on how
laboratories and pathology groups should develop partnerships with selected
payers, rooted in added value services that generate ample reimbursement. In
this first of a two-part series, Kaplan also delivers a dose of reality to
laboratories as he advises them on how to prepare for the marketplace changes
coming in the next five years.
CMS Anti-Markup Rules Target In-Office Ancillaries
Changes ahead for
specialist doctors using TC/PC arrangements or operating AP
labs
CEO SUMMARY: Medicare
officials are again attempting to rein in what they consider to be potentially
abusive forms of inoffice ancillary services, including anatomic pathology.
Proposed new rules published this month would clarify and perhaps expand the
application of the Medicare anti-markup for purchased diagnostic testing
services and for diagnostic tests provided by an ordering physician or supplier,
including the professional and technical components.
INTELLIGENCE: Late &
Latent
GENOME PROJECT ADDS 3 COMPANIES
MORE ON: UroPath
Complete Issue > Volume XV, Number 9, Monday, July 7, 2008 (July 7th, 2008 — $ 36.00) Click here to add this article to your cart
R. Lewis Dark:
Era of Digital Pathology
Steadily Approaches
IMMEDIATELY AFTER GENERAL ELECTRIC ANNOUNCED its partnership with the
University of Pittsburgh Medical Center (UPMC) on June 5 to develop a
fully integrated digital pathology system,we took a closer look at how some
pioneering pathologists are using digital imaging systems in their daily
clinical practice. What we found is that the technology is fairly well developed
and, in some other countries, pathologists already use digital pathology images
for primary diagnoses on a regular basis. That won�t happen in the United States
until the FDA clears this type of technology for clinical
applications.
To share what we learned with you, we provide an
intelligence briefing on pages 12-13 about how pathologists at the University
Health Network (UHN), in Toronto, Ontario, have used digital pathology for
frozen sections with great success for several years.Using ScanScope, a digital
imaging system from Aperio Technologies, Inc., the UHN pathologists have
improved workflow and patient care. They now regularly use the system to
transmit images over the Internet from surgical sites around the corner or from
a hospital 400 miles north of Toronto. By allowing pathologists to work
remotely, the system supports the pathology needs of hospitals where no regular
pathologist is on-site.
To be sure, companies developing fully-integrated
digital pathology systems face plenty of hurdles. That's the topic of our second
intelligence briefing, found on pages 15-18. We interviewed two CEOs of
companies that sell pathology imaging products and systems to learn their views
about howthe pathology profession is likely to react to digital pathology
technology which holds the potential to eventually move pathologists away from
glass slides and microscopes.
Repeatedly over the past decade, THE
DARK REPORT has reminded its clients and regular readers about the strategic
implications of baby boomer demographics.As experienced pathologists begin
retiring in significant numbers, it will be new technologies�including
fully-digital pathology imaging systems�that will become useful tools for
increasing the productivity of individual pathologists. These same technologies
will also contribute to improvements in the clinical quality delivered by
pathologists to physicians and patients. As you will read in this issue, the
sustained success of Toronto's UHN pathologists in using fully-digitized,
whole-slide pathology images for frozen sections offers some fascinating reasons
why the era of digital pathology may be closer than we all think.
NY & California Act to Stop Web Gene Testing Firms
Regulators in New York
and California target certain Web-based genetic testing
companies
CEO SUMMARY: Events in
the past month indicate that a war is developing between Internet-based
companies offering genetic tests to consumers and state and federal health
regulators. New York state authorities have sent letters to at least 31 such
companies in recent months. Then, on June 9, the California Department of Health
sent cease-and-desist letters to 13 Web firms. Just days later, the Federal
Trade Commission disclosed two investigations of genetic testing
companies.
Hospital Trends: Growth of Medical Tourism May Become Political
Issue
Americans going overseas
for healthcare mean fewer patients visiting hospitals in this
country
HealthPartners Promotes Same-Day Lab Test Results
In Minneapolis, walking
urine collection cup educates consumers about speedy lab
reports
CEO SUMMARY: Patient
focus groups told HealthPartners that they had anxiety as they waited days for
lab test results. That encouraged HealthPartners to redesign workflows in its
pathology department. Once it could deliver same-day lab test results
electronically,HealthPartners launched a uniquemarketing campaign to educate
consumers about this benefit in early May.Already,HealthPartners reports a
28%increase in the number of patients going on-line to access their lab test
results.
Toronto Pathologists Use Whole-Slide Imaging
Digital pathology and
whole-slide imaging increase concordance and pathology
productivity
CEO SUMMARY: It was the
�frozen section problem� and productivity issues that led pathologists at the
three-hospital University Health Network (UHN) in Toronto to implement a
fully-digital pathology system with whole-slide imaging in 2006. Use of digital,
whole-slide images makes it faster to report results to the surgeon,while making
it easier to involve colleagues in difficult cases. Now UHN's pathologists use
the system to support hospitals 400 miles away.
Is Digital Path Imaging Ready for Prime Time?
FDA clearance of digital
pathology imaging is one factor that will encourage wider
adoption
CEO SUMMARY: Digital
pathology imaging systems are finding uses in all phases of drug discovery
(discovery, preclinical, clinical trials), as well as education, research, and
clinical. One hurdle to widespread adoption of fully digitized, whole-slide
pathology imaging systems is FDA clearance that allows the use of this
technology for primary diagnosis. Executives at two of companies offering
digital pathology systems offer their predictions about how this market will
evolve.
INTELLIGENCE: Late &
Latent
SPENDING CUTS ADVERSELY AFFECT
CANADIAN LABS
CANCER-DETECTING MICROCHIP
UNVEILED
Complete Issue > Volume XV, Number 8, Monday, June 16, 2008 (June 16th, 2008 — $ 36.00) Click here to add this article to your cart
R. Lewis Dark:
Era of Digitized Pathology
Systems Approaches
SURGICAL PATHOLOGISTS SHOULD GET READY! I predict that they will soon
have the opportunity to purchase and use fully digital, automated pathology
systems that can perform primary diagnosis.When that happens, it will mark the
final cycle of the era when the principal method of diagnosing tissue was that
of eyeballs fixed to microscopes, scanning cells as glass slides are pushed
around the stage.
The introduction of digital pathology systems capable
of primary diagnosis will likely be the single most disruptive event to anatomic
pathology in the past two decades. That�s because automation of the primary
diagnosis of tissue will upend current work flow and clinical practices in
surgical pathology.
I make this prediction, based on two market
developments in anatomic pathology. One development is the success of Aperio
Technologies, Inc., in placing fully digital pathology systems in as many as 375
laboratories in 25 countries. This company is finding a ready market for its
digital solutions that support existing pathology work flow and clinical
practices.
The second market development is the long-awaited entry of
General Electric into laboratory medicine. As you will read on pages 9-11, GE
Healthcare is partnering with some of the best minds in digital pathology at the
University of Pittsburgh Medical Center (UPMC) to create Omnyx,
LLC. The aim is to develop digital pathology systems that can integrate the
transmission and use of digitized pathology images across the care continuum,
support improved workflow, and contribute to increased clinical quality� as well
as automate primary diagnosis. The two partners estimate that the market for
digitized pathology systems will be about $2 billion per year.
I suspect
GE is making this move now because it believes it has digital and other
technologies that can be transformational to anatomic pathology. It wants to
leverage its experience at digitizing radiology and evolving radiologists into a
fully digital work flow by doing the same in anatomic pathology. In the 1990s,
such companies as NeoPath, Inc., and Neuromedical Systems, Inc.,
privately showed THE DARK REPORT how digital cytology systems and
software algorithms could do accurate, automated primary diagnosis on a variety
of tissue types. Now the question is: are surgical pathologists ready to accept
digital pathology systems that can move them away from microscopes and in front
of computer screens? GE's entry into thismarketplace is evidence that it
believes the answer is: "Yes!"
NPI Rules Slow Payments To Pathology Groups, Labs
Private payers and
Medicare carriers kick out high volume of claims for incorrect NPI
compliance
CEO SUMMARY: New rules
requiring use of National Provider Identification (NPI) numbers took effect on
May 23. Since then, Medicare carriers and payers nationwide have rejected claims
from pathologists and other providers that do not comply with the new NPI rules.
A missing NPI on just one claim will result in the front end rejection of the
entire submission file to Medicare. Cash flow to some pathology groups and other
physicians has dropped. It may be another month or more before normal cash flow
is restored.
GE, UPMC Create Company For Digital Path Imaging
Joint venture estimates
market potential is $2 billion for fully-digitized pathology
systems
CEO SUMMARY: It's a new
joint venture with the potential to transform surgical pathology. General
Electric Healthcare has extensive experience at supporting physicians' work flow
with digitized imaging systems, plus ample experience with molecular biomarkers.
The University of Pittsburgh Medical Center's pathology department is a world
leader in whole-slide imaging and digitized pathology systems. Together, the two
partners hope to gain FDA approval for a fully digitized pathology system in
about two years.
New Senate Bills Include Repeal of Competitive Bid
Bills would kill lab
competitive bidding demo, eliminate cut to physician fees, and extend
TC
CEO SUMMARY: One
proposed Senate bill would repeal the laboratory competitive bidding
demonstration project, replace the 10.1% cut to physician fees with a 1.1%
increase, and extend the so-called technical component (TC) grandfather clause.
Senator Max Baucus (D-Montana), Chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, is
sponsor of the bill (called S 3101). Congress is under pressure to pass a
Medicare funding bill before July 1, 2008, when the 10.1% reduction in physician
fees will occur.
ISO 15189 Work Advances At Meeting in Vancouver
Delegates to ISO
Technical Committee 212 gathered for their annual working
session
CEO SUMMARY: Laboring
quietly out of the public eye, an international work team of professionals,
including representatives from the CDC, the FDA, and global in vitro diagnostics
(IVD) manufacturers, has spent the past 14 years developing an important series
of quality and safety standards for medical (clinical) laboratories. Here�s a
report on events at the most recent international assembly of ISO Technical
Committee 212, which gathered earlier this month in Vancouver, British
Columbia.
CMS Expected to Revise Condo Lab & TC/PC Rules
Rule changes could come
this summer and may also involve physician self-referral
CEO SUMMARY:
Expectations are that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS)
will take further action to rein in anatomic pathology arrangements used by
physicians to capture revenue from their patient referrals. This may happen as
soon as next month, when CMS publishes the 2009 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule
(MPFS) Update and requests public comment on proposed new rules. Attorneys
tracking these developments believe that both anatomic pathology condo labs and
TC/PC arrangements are likely to be the subject of these new
rules.
INTELLIGENCE: Late &
Latent
GENOME PROJECT ADDS 3 COMPANIES
SONIC ACQUIRES GERMAN LAB
FIRM
Complete Issue > Volume XV, Number 7, Monday, May 27, 2008 (May 27th, 2008 — $ 36.00) Click here to add this article to your cart
R. Lewis Dark:
Customer-Focused Labs Are
Successful
AS
YOU READ THIS ISSUE, YOU WILL BE AMONG THE FIRST in the laboratory industry to
learn that more than 50% of the nation's hospitals are financially deficient and
"technically insolvent or at risk of insolvency." That's according to Alvarez
& Marsal of New York City, which analyzed the financial performance of 3,900
hospitals and released a report on its findings. (See pages
10-14.)
Certainly for hospital-based lab directors and pathologists,
this may be one of the most significant intelligence briefings we bring you this
year. It is a sobering fact that, by Alvarez & Marsal's estimate, "2,044
hospitals, or 53% of the sample, had negative patient care profitability." That
means revenues from treating patients are not enough to cover expenses at these
struggling hospitals. Alvarez & Marsal observe: "A 'flight to (perceived)
quality' is occurring by both physicians and patients—creating a bigger gap
between the fiscally strong and fiscally weak hospitals in a given market." Why
are successful hospitals consistently profitable and capturingmarket share from
weaker hospitals? Experts such as Alvarez & Marsal and McKinsey & Co.
say the better hospitals succeed because they are close to their customers and
offer quality care, an attractive facility, and customerfocused personal service
to patients.
Success from a customer-facing and customer-focused business
strategy is one common theme heard in many of the presentations delivered at
this year’s Executive War College on Lab and Pathology Management, which took
place in Miami earlier this month. As you will read on pages 3-6, lab industry
leaders, innovators, and healthcare experts from such diverse, respected
companies as Microsoft, Cerner Corporation, and DNA Direct all had a common
element in their strategic recommendations to lab directors and pathologists. It
was that providers and laboratories must be close to their customers to survive
and thrive as ongoing reforms alter and transform the American healthcare
system.
If you askme, it’s not a coincidence that, in two different
intelligence briefings in this issue of THEDARK REPORT—and within two entirely
different segments of healthcare and laboratory medicine—the “customer-focused”
strategy is identified as a critical success factor. Observant lab executives
and pathologists will want to act upon this highly useful insight. It can play a
vital role in contributing to clinical excellence and financial viability in the
coming, tough years.
War College 2008 Theme: Get Close to Customers!
What's hot in laboratory
and pathology is customer-facing organizations and integrated
IT
CEO SUMMARY: Over the
course of two days, pathologists, lab directors, and other laboratory
professionals repeatedly heard speakers urge them to work hard to ensure that
customers are the top priority for their laboratory organization. Another theme
is the need for labs to organize their data so that they can send actionable
information to referring physicians and other partners in the healthcare system.
Forward-looking labs and pathology groups are already forging ahead with
enriched consultative services for client physicians.
Lab Industry’s First Mergers & Acquisitions Day Reveals Lots
of Interest, More Lab Sales Ahead
Cerner's Market-Driven Employee Health Program
Meet "Healthe", Cerner's
innovative effort to motivate employees to improve their
health
CEO SUMMARY: Cerner
Corporation is using a variety of strategies to reduce the cost of health
benefits and improve the quality of care for its workers and dependents. Gluing
the entire effort together is an integrated patient health record (PHR) and a
host of electronic services, ranging from real time eligibility verification and
claims adjudication for physicians to preventive and wellness programs for
employees. Last year, Cerner tracked $2.6 million in savings from this Healthe
initiative. It also began selling this innovative health benefits program to
other corporations.
New Report Says Half Nation's Hospitals Have Financial
Woes
Not Enough Patient-Care
Revenue to Cover Costs
CEO SUMMARY: In a
groundbreaking study just released, consulting firm Alvarez & Marsal
determined that as many as half of the nation's hospitals are failing to
generate enough patient revenue to sustain expenses! With a median occupancy
rate of 43%, these hospitals are likely to experience a wave of bankruptcies,
financial restructurings, and forced mergers. This is the second major report in
24 months to describe how and why many hospitals are failing to compete
effectively against physician-owned facilities and why consumers are voting with
their feet.
Ruling Against UroPath Signals More Fed Action
Expect CMS to develop new
anti-markup regs, based on federal court ruling in UroPath
case
CEO SUMMARY: It was a
signal win for federal healthcare officials when a federal district court judge
in Washington, DC, dismissed a case brought by UroPath, LLC. UroPath had sued
HHS Secretary Michael Leavitt seeking to challenge the physician fee schedule
final order and the anti-markup rule. The judge’s decision provides Medicare
officials with useful guidance on how to craft new regulations to possibly
further limit the way anatomic pathology condominium (pod) labs operate. Two lab
industry attorneys offer insights about what may happen next in this
case.
Federal Court Rules on Specimen Ownership
Growing research value of
human specimens leads to lawsuit between physician and
university
CEO SUMMARY: Recently, a
federal appeals court affirmed a district court ruling concerning who owns human
tissue specimens that are stored for research and other uses. While most
clinical laboratories routinely discard many types of human specimens after use,
any research facility or IVD manufacturer that retains specimens should review
the new legal issues raised by this court decision. The case of Washington
University versus Catalona demonstrates how legal battles over ownership and
control of human specimens may lead to significant new legal
precedents.
INTELLIGENCE: Late &
Latent
MORE ON: Cell Phones Aid
Diagnostics
RFID TO TRACK LAB
SPECIMENS
Complete Issue > Volume XV, Number 6, Monday, May 5, 2008 (May 5th, 2008 — $ 36.00) Click here to add this article to your cart
R. Lewis Dark:
Battles Continue Over Doctor
Mark Up of Lab Tests
FROM THE SHADOWS OF A PARKING GARAGE, Deep Throat suggests to
reporter Bob Woodward, "Follow the money." In this scene from the movie, All the
President�s Men, Woodward gets the right advice he needs from an unnamed source
to pursue the Watergate case, a huge political scandal of the
1970s.
"Follow the money" is also good advice for lab managers and
pathologists tracking the battles over physician mark-ups of clinical laboratory
testing and anatomic pathology (AP) services. Efforts of the federal Centers
for Medicaid & Medicare Services (CMS) to implement proposed rules
preventing physicians from marking up certain laboratory, pathology, and
radiology services have been widely publicized. Now legislators in Missouri are
considering changing state law to prohibit physicians from marking up fees for
pathology services."In some medical practices across Missouri, doctors are
turning a profit from lab work done by other doctors. And most patients and
their insurance companies don�t know about it," says an article in the
Springfield News Leader in Missouri on April 30."It�s called 'indirect
billing' or 'pass-through arrangements,' and a bill in theMissouri legislature
would outlaw the practice."
The sponsor of Senate Bill 817 is Missouri
state Senator Jack Goodman (R Mount Vernon). He believes it�s unethical for
physicians to mark up fees for work performed by other physicians. A similar
measure, House bill 1990, is expected to be assigned to a committee. Two earlier
efforts to pass such bills failed. Missouri physicians have testified in favor
of retaining the ability to mark up test fees, saying it allows them to
negotiate discounts with labs and guarantees their patients a set package price
for in-office tests and lab work. They claim this can allow them to pass on
discounts to low-income and insured patients. But no one has stepped forward
with evidence documenting that physicians do, in fact, pass these discounts
along to self-paying patients.
I suspect federal officials will prevail
in their efforts to prohibit physicians from marking up laboratory tests,
anatomic pathology services, and radiology procedures not performed in their
offices by board-certified physicians who are partners/employees of the medical
group. As that happens, private payers will fall into line with similar
anti-markup requirements. After all, if you follow the money, Medicare,
Medicaid, and private health insurers have much more to lose than office-based
physicians have to gain from banning mark-up arrangements.
Lab Automation Advocates Gather in Kobe, Japan
Sixth Biannual "Cherry
Blossom Symposium" provides look at the cutting edge of lab
automation
CEO SUMMARY: CEO
SUMMARY: Everything relating to automation in clinical laboratory operations was
the theme of the sixth "International Conference of Laboratory Automation and
Robotics," conducted last month in Kobe, Japan. Because laboratories in Japan,
Korea, and Taiwan have two and three decades of experiencewith extensive
automation, presentations at this gathering are quite sophisticated and reveal
that these laboratories are continuing to push forward in their use of
automation.
University of Tokyo Hospital Lab Has Plenty of Automation
Phlebotomy is supported
by extensive automation, most interesting is the automated urine transport
line
CEO SUMMARY: In Japan,
many clinical laboratories are in their third decade of using automation. At the
University of Tokyo Hospital, total laboratory automation (TLA) was first
implemented in 1991. Now on its fourth generation TLA system, this laboratory
was worked upstream to automate specimen collection and urine collection,
transport, and specimen preparation. The result is automation solutions not seen
in the United States.
Technology Update: Healthcare Has First Standards for Use of Bar
Codes and RFID
ANSI and two healthcare
groups collaborate to develop standards to support these
technologies
Managed Care Update: Cell Phones to be Used to Report Patient
Self-Test Results
CareFirst Blue Cross Blue
Shield of Maryland ready to launch diabetes management
service
Implementing Best Practices Across 27 Hospital Labs
Management Strategies to
Share "Best Practices" Across All Lab Sites
CEO SUMMARY: It is
always challenging to ensure consistency and high productivity across the
different labs in a consolidated lab organization. To help staff focus on
quality and efficiency, Alverno Clinical Laboratories LLC uses Lean methods to
improve quality and timely delivery of lab results in its regional core
laboratory and the labs in the 27 affiliated hospitals in Illinois and Indiana.
This strategy helped Alverno save almost $11 million last year while turning out
14 million billable tests.
PhyTest Assists Doctors With Lab Testing Revenue
Georgia-based company has
exclusive focus to help doctors with laboratory testing
programs
CEO SUMMARY: PhyTest,
Inc., created a unique business model upon its founding in 1998. It primarily
specializes in handling laboratory test billing and collection services to
office-based physicians. It also provides evaluation, consulting, and
implementation services to help physicians in client-bill states establish
discounted billing relationships with reference laboratories. To avoid Stark Law
issues on physician self-referral, these arrangements do not involve laboratory
testing done for patients covered by Medicare or other federal health
programs.
INTELLIGENCE: Late &
Latent
JAPAN�S HEALTH SYSTEM TACKLES
PREVENTIVE CARE
MEDICAL JOURNAL HITS
MISDIAGNOSIS
Complete Issue > Volume XV, Number 5, Monday, April 14, 2008 (April 14th, 2008 — $ 36.00) Click here to add this article to your cart
|
|
|
|

|
R. Lewis Dark:
Courts Uphold Labs'
Challenges on CMS' Rules
SINCE MARCH 31, THE FEDERAL CENTERS FOR MEDICARE & MEDICAID
SERVICES (CMS) has lost two decisions in two different U.S. district courts.
Though each case addressed fundamentally different issues, the rulings were
remarkably similar. In both cases, the courts questioned CMS� failure to
properly use federal procedures.We provide analysis on both cases in this
issue.
Each case has been widely reported. One involves the three San
Diego-area laboratories which went to federal district court and filed suit to
prevent CMS from moving forward with the Medicare Laboratory Competitive Bidding
Demonstration Project in the San Diego-Carlsbad-San Marcos metropolitan
statistical area (MSA). (See pages 3-7.) The second case was filed in the U.S.
District Court inWashington,DC, by anatomic pathology condo/pod lab company
UroPath, LLC, and its affiliates, seeking to delay and overturn
implementation of the anti-markup rule that became effective on January 1, 2008.
(See pages 8-9.) Since March 31, judges in both federal court cases have
ruled in favor of the plaintiff laboratory organizations.
This is
instructive on several points. For one, every time labs seek redress through
CMS� administrative procedures, invariably the administrative judge rules
against the laboratory and in favor of CMS. Thus, it is significant that two
federal district court judges, in courts 3,000 miles apart, both slapped the
government on the hand and granted the request for injunctions by the plaintiff
labs.
Next, each judge's ruling has a common theme: In the San Diego
case, the judge ruled that CMS was required to follow the notice and comment
requirements of the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) of 1946 as it developed
the Medicare Laboratory Competitive Bidding Demonstration Project. In the
Washington, DC, case, the federal judge ruled that CMS was required to follow
the notice and comment requirements of the APA when it proposed regulatory
changes using the 2008 Medicare Physician Fee Update process.
These two
federal judges have delivered justifiable setbacks to the bureaucrats at CMS. It
is amessage to CMS that it is not above the law! Further, as you will read
elsewhere in this issue, these two federal court cases may establish a welcome
precedent that CMS must follow APA requirements on every competitive bidding
demonstration that it wants to implement. Be forewarned, however: neither of
these federal court cases is concluded and government attorneys have yet to
respond to the injunctions in both cases.
Three San Diego Labs Stop Competitive Bid Demo
Federal judge issues
injunction preventing CMS officials from proceeding with demo
pilot
CEO SUMMARY: Last
Tuesday, a federal judge handed a big court victory to the three plaintiffs in
their lawsuit seeking to delay or stop implementation of the Medicare Laboratory
Competitive Bidding Demonstration pilot in the San Diego area. In his written
opinion, the judge ruled in favor of the plaintiffs on three key points and
issued a preliminary injunction. It is now up to federal attorneys to respond to
the judge�s decision.
April 4 Fed Court Ruling Opened Door to Injunction
Three San Diego labs had
to first prevail on three legal issues for their case to
proceed
CEO SUMMARY: Federal
Judge Thomas J. Whelan's ruling on three key legal points on Friday, April 4,was
the first court victory needed by three San Diego-area labs in their lawsuit to
prevent the Medicare Laboratory Competitive Bidding Demonstration in San Diego
from proceeding. Judge Whelan ruled that the three plaintiff labs: 1) did not
have to exhaust administrative remedies before turning to court; 2) a judicial
review of these claims is not barred by law; and, 3) standards for ripeness and
standing are met.
Litigation Update: Federal Judge to Look at CMS Rule-Making in
Anti-Markup Case
Hospital Lab Evolves Into A Consultative Resource
Hospital-wide initiative
to educate clinicians on lab test utilization leads to
improvements
CEO SUMMARY: Every
laboratory recognizes it has the knowledge and expertise to become more of a
consultative resource to its referring physicians. At 248-bed J.T. Mather
Hospital in Port Jefferson, New York, the laboratory director took advantage of
adminstration�s interest in improving laboratory test utilization by creating an
enriched program of education and collaboration. The effort has paid off, as
measured by changes in lab test ordering patterns for targeted
assays.
Lab Automation Viewed As Essential Solution
Automated systems help
lab boost efficiency as a strategy to meet lab workforce
challenges
CEO SUMMARY: A merger of
three hospitals in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, forced PinnacleHealth's lab
director to find newways to increase efficiency. A lab automation project helped
improve turnaround time and staff productivity and cut costs. The cost savings
is about 50 cents per test, which means the lab automation project is savingmore
than $1 million in annual operating costs.The key to getting the project
approved was the savings on cost per test and having a proposal that matched the
hospital's strategic plan.
Notable People: Quality Guru Joseph M. Juran Dies Six Weeks Ago at
Age 103
He recognized that a
small number of problems generate most quality issues, coined "80-20
Rule"
INTELLIGENCE: Late &
Latent
MORE ON: Mood Disorders
TRANSITIONS |
|