|
R.
Lewis Dark: Survivor: Three Labs Shake Out Into Two
TELEVISION'S "SURVIVOR" IS THE UNFOLDING STORY of how one person
competes to outlast 16 fellow players in a remote outdoor setting. The
winner of "Survivor" walks away with a $1 million prize. The show has
proven to be popular and is now airing episodes of its fourth group of
competitors, stuck on a tropical island in the South Pacific.
Since the early 1990s, competition among public lab companies has been
intense. The number of competitors declined steadily. The process was
much like the TV show "Survivor." One at a time, lab companies would
falter and disappear from the marketplace. Their labs, their clients,
and their employees would be absorbed by a surviving lab company,
usually through acquisition.
Thus, it was 1995 when the public lab industry ended up with three
billion-dollar lab companies. They were Quest Diagnostics Incorporated,
Laboratory Corporation of America, and SmithKline Beecham Clinical
Laboratories (SBCL). Here is where my story begins. In a national market
overshadowed by three billion-dollar lab testing behemoths, one was to
pursue a business strategy that would make it the true survivor in the
public lab consolidation game.
Around the offices of THE DARK REPORT, we remember the comments made by
Quest Diagnostics CEO Ken Freeman in the years following its 1997
spin-off from Corning Corporation. Freeman observed publicly that, in
any industry where three companies were large and dominant, economic
forces invariably worked to eliminate one of the three. In this business
analysis of his company's situation, it became a strategic goal of Quest
Diagnostics to survive this expected shake-out.
Thus, when Quest Diagnostics acquired SBCL in 1999, it did not surprise
those in the lab industry who understood the business strategy
underpinning this acquisition. Freeman was taking active steps to insure
the survival of his company by pushing the commercial lab industry
into the two-company oligopoly that it is today and making Quest
Diagnostics one of its two survivors.
I think this story is relevant for hospital lab administrators and
pathologists. At a regional level, these same management dynamics argue
that metropolitan areas dominated by three major hospitals or health
systems will eventually see that number reduced to just two. For that
reason, hospital labs and pathology groups in such cities should
develop a business strategy that insures they are one of the two
survivors!
More Lab Consolidation: LabCorp Buys Dynacare
LabCorp gains entry into new regional markets and expands into Canada
CEO Summary: Recent weeks brought many rumors about an impending deal between Laboratory Corporation of America and Dynacare.
That speculation was ended last week when it was disclosed that LabCorp would pay about $685 million in cash, stock and assumed debt to acquire Dynacare. The aquisition also spells the end to Dynacare's strategy developing lab testing joint ventures with hospitals.
Specialty Labs Coping With Unique Challenges
Regulatory sanctions and lab consolidation each require a detailed management response
CEO
Summary: Few laboratory executives have ever been tested as intensely as those of Specialty Laboratories, Inc. Since the first of the year, Quest Diagnostics Inc. has purchased two of its biggest lab clients. In April, state and federal lab regulators
issued sanctions. Both developments are rolling the market for the hospital send-out testing.
High Cost of New Assays Stretching Lab Budgets
Increased Costs of New Test Technologies are Busting Hospital Laboratory
Budgets
Increased costs of new test technologies are busting hospital laboratory budgets
CEO
Summary: Growing numbers of hospital labs report that higher costs
of new diagnostic tests have become a new management problem. That's
because diagnostic manufacturers are developing tests around a new
business model, one that calls for higher pricing based on a premise of
higher clinical value. Marketing campaigns for these new assays will
become increasingly sophisticated and pervasive.
Is Physicians' Office Testing Evolving Toward an Oligopoly?
Commercial Lab Consolidation is The Culprit
CEO
Summary: One of the most unpopular industries with consumers is the
airline industry. At the national level, it is an oligopoly—dominated by
seven carriers. But in many cities, it is a monopoly, with one airline
flying 80% of the seats in and out of town. Ongoing consolidation of
regional commercial labs by the Two Blood Brothers is creating a
parallel situation in the lab industry segment serving physicians'
offices. Nationally, that market segment is now an oligopoly. But in
many cities, it is already a monopoly, dominated by one national lab
company. Consequences of this trend will soon be obvious.
Calif. Lab Regulators are a Tough Bunch
Other public lab companies in Golden State have run afoul of state
laboratory regulations
CEO
Summary: By law, government regulators cannot comment publicly about
the actions they take against the companies they regulate. That's why
the lab industry never learned that other public lab companies operaing
in California, following inspections by state authorities, were judged
to have some deficiencies similar to those found at Specialty
Laboratories.
Public Laboratory Rankings:2001 Another Year of Fast Growth!
General Reference Labs, Niche and Pathology Lab Companies
INTELLIGENCE:
DIANON Posts Strong Growth
First "ID Chips" Implanted in Humans
Beckman Coulter Reports Earnings
|